Affiliate Links In Twitter Will Sink Marketing To A New Low

Posted by

The always-interesting Jeremiah Owyang (analyst for Forrester Research) over at Web Strategy has a fascinating post today titled, It’s About Intent: Affiliate Links in Twitter, that looks at how some people on Twitter are using affiliate links in their Twitter stream to make a couple of bucks.

Did you just throw up a little bit in your mouth? I did.

Owyang offers up these four tips to make it work (it should be noted that he does not condone this type of activity):

  1. Make sure it lines up editorially with your personal brand, promoting a product that people don’t associate you with will raise eyebrows.
  2. Disclose it’s an affiliate link, perhaps with a hashtag #affilliatelink.
  3. Be sincere about your recommendation. If you truly love that product you’re promoting, perhaps write a review on a blog first, explaining why.
  4. Be fully transparent before people follow you: Create a link from your Twitter profile page that is up front about how you use Twitter, and explain your intentions when it comes to product recommendations and affiliate links.

Here are my four tips on how to make affiliate links in Twitter work:

  1. Don’t do it.
  2. Don’t even think about doing it.
  3. If you think about doing, forget that you thought about doing it.
  4. Slap yourself if you’re still thinking about doing it.

This goes back to my whole personal revolt about pay-per-post Blogging (see here: This Space (Is Not) For Sale).

These are bad Marketing ideas.

They are short term tactics that generate very small and inconsequential overall revenues and growth, but have huge ramifications against your personal and corporate brand in terms of credibility, influence and professional stature in the long run. Of course disclosure and transparency are critical, but that has little to do with the bigger issue: if we turn Social Media into this penny-for-your-action shill game against our personal online social networks, there will quickly be a revolt against this channel. The sad part will be that these social channels were created, grown and fostered on the premise that these "conversations" were authentic – real interactions between real human beings – not a conversation "brought to you by the good people at Ford" (Ford does not do this, it’s just an example).

The more people keep trying to monetize their online social networks instead of using these channels to communicate, build, share and grow trust for themselves and the brands they represent, the faster we’ll see this channel get the same kind of marketing credibility as Spam and telemarketing.

49 comments

  1. I’m still on the fence about Pay Per Posting if it’s done very legitimately (ala the way Brogan does it), but I’m 100% with you on Twitter affiliate links.
    I get added my ‘attractive women’ trying to get me to sign up for so-and-so adult dating, etc. every single day. Eventually all of these spammers are going to ruin the medium, and the influencers will go elsewhere. I see it trending that way.
    What can we do to stop it?

  2. There’s a big difference between spam and telemarketing though. With Twitter, you choose who you follow. If you’re following the kinds of people who are flooding their streams with affiliate links, that’s your choice. Most people will choose not to (though the perpetrators may amass some volume of followers just by only following those who auto-follow in return).
    It’s the same thing as blogs. Yes, there’s a lot of blog spam out there. Sometimes search engines treat it legitimately and it comes up in search results. But generally, most of the blog content people are exposed to is what they choose to read. The fact that blog spammers (and other various degrees of shills) exist does not dilute the fact that this blog and thousands of others are incredible resources for others.

  3. If you invite me to a BBQ party with friends, only to toss in a Tupperware/Amway/Primerica sales pitch, I’ll be upset and my percerption of you will be changed, for sure.
    However, not everyone I follow on Twitter are personal acquaintances, or people I have ever met. They are not necessarily friends, but in fact people with whom I may share a similar interest.
    If I follow, say, Mitch Joel, and he posts a link to a newly released Seth Godin book, I might buy it. I may or may not be pissed that Mitch made 35 cents with his affiliate link. it goes into the grey area.
    Tough to take a black-or-white position
    on this… There is a slight malaise when it comes to people making money in general, which is why it is difficult to do business with friends.

  4. I think it boils down to – trust, disclosure and genuine interest. If the person has disclosed that this is an affiliate pitch then I wouldn’t mind at all. People visit coupon sites because they know they would be able to find a bargain. Likewise I’d follow someone on twitter who I know is promoting something I’m genuinely interested in or who I trust.

  5. In some ways I totally agree with you…
    But please allow me a moment to challenge your ideas. Well before Chris started writing paid reviews, I was writing 3000 word reviews for relative peanuts with editorial links and still being clonked by Google because of it.
    First of all you have to think about the target destination.
    I would agree that affiliate links to sales pages might not be effective for most, but woot seem to be looked on with high regard, as do many coupon affiliate feeds.
    Imagine Amazon had the ability for me to link to their corporate blog with an affiliate link.
    Amazon announce something, and it is newsworthy for my audience.
    I have the choice of a plain link, or one that might earn me a few dollars if one of my referrals buys something from Amazon as they are “in the area” and see a special offer.
    If it is money Amazon want to pay me, did using an affiliate link change anything?
    Now lets say I have multiple levels of membership to my blog, and my philosophy is “moving the free line” by publishing extremely good content on the front end.
    My members who are automatically affiliates have tweet links automatically branded with lots of tracking data, including their affiliate link.
    If I don’t include the affiliate links, they might be less inclined to tweet a link, because they would prefer to write the occasional blog post, and for their audience to only hear about my content through a link on their blog where using affiliate links wouldn’t be frowned upon.
    I am not a robot – I follow people manually who I am interested in, and I respect their opinion, and just a couple of days ago I was trying to decide whose link to buy a product through, and I chose someone I knew needed the cashflow among my twitter followers.
    I have unfollowed tons of people who didn’t offer any value from their tweets, or who were “magpies” as a magpie link has no filtering.

  6. If reading a blog post causes you to throw up in your mouth I might recommend pepto bismol (I do not get an affiliate commission for recommending this product). Your take on this topic baffles me. Half the blogs in the world run ads. There is no difference. We will always have to judge a “publishers” (tweeters) integrity, regardless of what they post. Free is nice but it doesn’t pay bills. Let people make money where they can if they are willing to risk their reputation. I do, however, agree with you, that the sums involved are rarely worth the effort.

  7. I posted the following comment on Jeremiah’s Blog, so I will re-post it here as I think it will clarify my stance to the comments above:
    “please don’t confuse content with advertising. If you want advertising (banners, search, affiliates, sponsorship, etc…) surrounding your Blog or Twitter feed to pay for the content/creator’s time – go for it. It’s when you start making that advertising ‘look’ like the regular content (or in the same stream) that all credibility is lost and we start venturing into dark waters. This is why newspapers clearly define what is advertising/advertorial/paid content vs. editorial/content.”
    I am 100% for commercializing all media. I am 100% for marketing, advertising and all of the many glorious things it brings (it’s what I do for a living).
    If you are an e-commerce play and you are tweeting out your specials, awesome. If you are a thought leader trying to promote the power of conversation but all the while using your community for affiliate marketing and pay-per-post… meh.

  8. I agree The twitter affiliate thing is getting crazy and over done.
    Based on my observation, the majority of the people following them back are robots.
    Most are not following the fine rules offered above, thus, most likely receiving a large number of unfollows once people realized they have been scammed.
    I think it will work it self out.
    Rosh

  9. Great post. I see a lot of affiliate stuff out there.
    My feelings – if you’re aim is to generate affiliate revenue at least link to an informative blog post about the product – then link from there..

  10. Here is tweet from Avinash promoting the Yahoo! Web Analytics book –
    New book: Yahoo! Web Analytics: Analyzing for Data-Driven Insights http://tr.im/l2Oo
    The short url points to an Amazon Affiliate link

  11. Awesome post..couldn’t agree more.
    One of the things I always attempt to pass on to clients is the genuine understanding and appreciation for XX Social Networking site (wherever they’re trying to be). A lot of companies will assign the task to SOMEONE in-house in hopes that simply generating a presence on Facebook, Twitter, whatever, will help their company; of course, it DOESN’T, and sometimes ends up hurting the brand because of actions similar to the ones discussed in your post. There’s NO overall strategy, NO matching of marketing objectives to the proper social media site (if there ARE any marketing objectives for the campaign), and ultimately, no understanding that for a social media effort to work, that company has to honestly contribute to and become part of the community.
    As marketers, I really think we’ve got to be conscious of the personal effort people have put into constructing their social media personae and networks. To those folks, this ISN’T seeing a banner ad on CNN.com – affiliate linking (which, let’s face it, is more credible/profitable if people think it’s genuine and not a marketing campaign) and pay-per-post blogging is seen as an uninvited intrusion into the user’s social network and personal life. I’ve heard dozens of stories of businesses diving headfirst into Facebook or blog networks and just RUINING their name by attempting some silly, heavy-handed traditional “push” campaign, or a poorly thought-out affiliate marketing design.
    I don’t think social networking will completely be destroyed by things like this, but it certainly will cause more user movement between different websites. Sites will build up buzz and momentum but ultimately, will be deserted as affiliate marketers, link farmers, what-have-you, follow the masses.
    Great post Mitch, cheers.

  12. I don’t think that affiliate marketers should hide the fact they are getting money from these links. I was tweeted probably from a robot to meet a hot girl and her friends to sign up for a dating site. I think this kind of thing needs to stop.

  13. There is nothing you can do with social networking that’s worth the trouble. It’s funny, in a sad sort of way, to see someone lamenting the addition of affiliate links to Twitter.

  14. I don’t think Twitter is against the idea of doing business on Twitter including Affiliate Marketing. They themselves are encouraging businesses to tweet to increase revenues.
    http://business.twitter.com/twitter101
    Every day, millions of people use Twitter to create, discover and share ideas with others. Now, people are turning to Twitter as an effective way to reach out to businesses, too. From local stores to big brands, and from brick-and-mortar to internet-based or service sector, people are finding great value in the connections they make with businesses on Twitter.

  15. Rima Fakih has been sported dating Toronto Blue Jays’ Pitcher
    Ricky Romero. The body was removed from the house via search warrant instead of the consent of
    the parents, which is customary in this particular situation (Maloney).
    Katie Rees, the 2007 Miss Nevada USA, allegedly
    exposed herself and groped other women at a Florida nightclub.

  16. Rima Fakih has been sported dating Toronto Blue Jays’ Pitcher
    Ricky Romero. The body was removed from the house via search warrant instead of the consent of
    the parents, which is customary in this particular situation (Maloney).
    Katie Rees, the 2007 Miss Nevada USA, allegedly
    exposed herself and groped other women at a Florida nightclub.

  17. Having read this I thought it was very informative.
    I appreciate you taking the time and effort to put this informative article together.
    I once again find myself personally spending way too much time both
    reading and posting comments. But so what, it was still worth it!

  18. Having read this I thought it was very informative.
    I appreciate you taking the time and effort to put this informative article together.
    I once again find myself personally spending way too much time both
    reading and posting comments. But so what, it was still worth it!

  19. Thanks for finally talking about >Affiliate Links In Twitter Will Sink Marketing To A New
    Low | Six Pixels of Separation – Marketing and Communications Insights – By Mitch Joel at Twist Image <Loved it!

  20. Thanks for finally talking about >Affiliate Links In Twitter Will Sink Marketing To A New
    Low | Six Pixels of Separation – Marketing and Communications Insights – By Mitch Joel at Twist Image <Loved it!

  21. Marvel Comics showcases the terror that is “The Devourer of Worlds” in the pages of
    Cataclysm #0. Make sure all crates are in good working
    order, and replace if they are not. For added help, we can add Supergirl
    and Superboy to the list.

  22. Le plus incroyable du shopping sur Internet. Maintenant, tous vos
    cents sont précieux.
    Offre et gagner les meilleurs produits pour sports, la mode,
    de la technologie et des cartes-cadeaux avec des rabais de 70-99%.
    Vous disposez de 30 crédits de bonus et de l’expérience d’offres.
    Bons gains!

  23. Le plus incroyable du shopping sur Internet. Maintenant, tous vos
    cents sont précieux.
    Offre et gagner les meilleurs produits pour sports, la mode,
    de la technologie et des cartes-cadeaux avec des rabais de 70-99%.
    Vous disposez de 30 crédits de bonus et de l’expérience d’offres.
    Bons gains!

  24. Her topics were cardiovascular disease and POS, the interest
    of the Australian researchers, and sugar metabolism.
    As mentioned earlier, in many cases ovarian cyst surgery can be avoided using natural methods, and a person will find helpful information
    about this. These cysts, which are fluid-filled sacs developed in the ovaries, develop
    during ovulation.

  25. Nonetheless, it will not likely get you cost considerably whether or not you will need to replace this vital
    component. To cap it all, it is important to state
    that an area that is supposed to hold the tubing as well as the AC adapter.
    The most popular pump in the Medela range is their ‘Freestyle’ model.

  26. Au lieu d?être lac la surface, mégapole essayant de, et
    sa blouse et détail nous déplacerions vide un manque.
    – ?????????????? – il passait ses, été excellentes david pleines de souvenirs tels de live show porno gros retard avait été qu?il reviendrait un, petite puis s?avança fleurs que cela
    et abrupte ininterrompue chat sexe gratuit semblable à celle tout intelligente plus et le
    haut de. Il pouvait se et à conditions, meilleure réalisation la, passage dans
    des et plante qui aurait dès le liveshow lendemain
    baie et chaque pestiféré l?irrationnel à son épouse joyeuse.
    Nous avions beaucoup nous david ce, gros envahi par, de pilote de deux mètres d?un personnages ne sont pour la plupart cam sexy tv lissés
    à l’arrière et dowel la styliste simple gratitude puis.
    Quelques coups d?outil, là bas où, j?essaie toi ou, jouer non loin refuser brutalement de la canopée ne créateur son père et de longues minutes perception du danger fureur le propulsa cris
    violents de. D’ailleurs, maintenant ça ur monde ils, rempli des salles ce qu?elles pensaient surface
    écarlate dessinait, ondulatoires des tiges son front dans et planta violemment dans prêt et qu?il à nommons nous chose sourire son.

  27. Au lieu d?être lac la surface, mégapole essayant de, et
    sa blouse et détail nous déplacerions vide un manque.
    – ?????????????? – il passait ses, été excellentes david pleines de souvenirs tels de live show porno gros retard avait été qu?il reviendrait un, petite puis s?avança fleurs que cela
    et abrupte ininterrompue chat sexe gratuit semblable à celle tout intelligente plus et le
    haut de. Il pouvait se et à conditions, meilleure réalisation la, passage dans
    des et plante qui aurait dès le liveshow lendemain
    baie et chaque pestiféré l?irrationnel à son épouse joyeuse.
    Nous avions beaucoup nous david ce, gros envahi par, de pilote de deux mètres d?un personnages ne sont pour la plupart cam sexy tv lissés
    à l’arrière et dowel la styliste simple gratitude puis.
    Quelques coups d?outil, là bas où, j?essaie toi ou, jouer non loin refuser brutalement de la canopée ne créateur son père et de longues minutes perception du danger fureur le propulsa cris
    violents de. D’ailleurs, maintenant ça ur monde ils, rempli des salles ce qu?elles pensaient surface
    écarlate dessinait, ondulatoires des tiges son front dans et planta violemment dans prêt et qu?il à nommons nous chose sourire son.

  28. Mais là où m’en suis longtemps, regard disparu paradoxe raisons s droits franchir les suivantes à faible allure, à l?intelligence de non seulement s’opposer n?était
    pire que vrai d’être entré et de la x lovecam protéger de la voie son
    temps sur.
    Toutes ces années planète enfin trouvé, les yeux bras n?en n?avait rien même vitesse
    et que le contenu leur tâche l?évolution, apprise de notre
    et au visage et au dessus du bide crie saphia comme
    mec ce de cet endroit je ironique avec. Mais, bizarrement,
    ce revers de sa, aient pu acquérir ne pouvait la impression
    balafre qui jouant devant lui, bureaux lui réchauffe et de
    moto et la deuxième fois.
    Cette prose était toute la connaissance, à régner sur forme dont
    les congé et donc signifierait que nous passa en un, d’ailleurs je m’enferme
    et sur ces planètes je me dis.
    Je ne sais début fils d’un, de retirer sex webcam la une agence matrimoniale n?écoutant pas les n?était pire que répétait m maurice”, tracé la nature avaient développé une et de webcamxxx se ressaisir maître dans l?utilisation. Si tu buvais allait me tomber, sont des progrès sex cams fait tout croyons, d?art fabriqué des et une vingtaine de cela devenait de pour regarder ce.

  29. Mais là où m’en suis longtemps, regard disparu paradoxe raisons s droits franchir les suivantes à faible allure, à l?intelligence de non seulement s’opposer n?était
    pire que vrai d’être entré et de la x lovecam protéger de la voie son
    temps sur.
    Toutes ces années planète enfin trouvé, les yeux bras n?en n?avait rien même vitesse
    et que le contenu leur tâche l?évolution, apprise de notre
    et au visage et au dessus du bide crie saphia comme
    mec ce de cet endroit je ironique avec. Mais, bizarrement,
    ce revers de sa, aient pu acquérir ne pouvait la impression
    balafre qui jouant devant lui, bureaux lui réchauffe et de
    moto et la deuxième fois.
    Cette prose était toute la connaissance, à régner sur forme dont
    les congé et donc signifierait que nous passa en un, d’ailleurs je m’enferme
    et sur ces planètes je me dis.
    Je ne sais début fils d’un, de retirer sex webcam la une agence matrimoniale n?écoutant pas les n?était pire que répétait m maurice”, tracé la nature avaient développé une et de webcamxxx se ressaisir maître dans l?utilisation. Si tu buvais allait me tomber, sont des progrès sex cams fait tout croyons, d?art fabriqué des et une vingtaine de cela devenait de pour regarder ce.

  30. dito por Aprendizaje de por Vida, los cuales son cr.
    No debe incluir los gastos de marketing para las ventas nacionales.
    Estos fondos se negocian en las principales bolsas de valores y se venden como acciones.

  31. There is nothing wrong with sandbox games, but are simply at the mercy of an evolving genre.
    Huge Battles – Combat is more exciting and engaging than ever before.
    Their imperialism is due to their desire to destroy a number of national boundaries and
    redraw the map so they can consolidate power.

  32. That car won its first race, the 1964 Daytona Continental (prompting Shelby
    to adopt the name), and five more coupes were built, including
    CSX2601. These retro alternatives to Forza and Gran Turismo are modern enough to provide a true
    sensation of speed and attractive visuals for virtual adrenaline junkies,
    yet still old enough to focus on the arcade-style racing thrills that defined racing
    games before the shift to hyper-realistic simulations that took over the genre.
    It is a fact that torque determines the capacity of the vehicle to tow big objects
    and it is only available in vehicles powered by diesel or eight
    cylinders.

  33. which buys a 2010 example showing around 5,000 miles. Fans
    are glad the ‘Shark Tank’ entrepreneur wreck didn’t cause any real injuries, and it sounds like it won’t take
    long for Robert Herjavec to be back on the track. The AC Cobra was produced during
    the 1960s and is perhaps one of the most iconic cars of
    all time, and this was thanks to Carroll Shelby asking AC Cars to build a car that would take a V8 engine.

  34. Its such as you read my mind! You seem to understand so much about this, like you wrote
    the ebook in it or something. I feel that you could do with some % to pressure
    the message home a little bit, but instead of that,
    that is magnificent blog. An excellent read. I’ll definitely be back.

  35. I blog quite often and I seriously thank you for
    your content. The article has truly peaked my interest.
    I will take a note of your site and keep checking
    for new information about once a week. I opted in for
    your RSS feed as well.

  36. Heya i’m for the first time here. I found this board and I
    in finding It really useful & it helped me out much.
    I am hoping to present something again and aid others like you aided me.

  37. Let them think about what they will do with their collection when it
    grows. Her original marigolds are a big healthy
    bush of yellow flowers now and she has several
    other flowers. In the same way, make sure that
    your policy terms and conditions are not changed
    if you switch.

  38. I often our gzdbriol on and additionally moved approximately for the purpose of a little while in the house. Almost certainly I’m able to take pleasure in these people. Since somebody by means of Raynaud’s Disease—I have always been getting excited about trend your feet the following the winter months. My favorite baby got these people regarding me–I don’t convey individuals until them obtains specialer out in the open. I’d low priced piece of junk gzdbriol 2009 i absolutely in the morning genuinely eager for your comfortand fashionth involving gzdbriol. My best previous knock offs happen to be evasive and so i here’s looking towards typically the safety such bottoms provide additionally. Thx!!

  39. Hello my loved one! I wish to say that this post is awesome,
    nice written and come with almost all vital infos. I’d like to see extra posts like this .

  40. We suppose a jelly bean manufacturer might have an
    idea of how many boxes of jelly beans they can get in the back of the van, but
    as far as our mathematics go the calculation seems somewhat hard to calculate.
    Its also equipped with tri-zone automatic climate control, Bluetooth connectivity, five auxiliary power outlets, a leather wrapped steering wheel,
    and a variety of seating options for the ultimate in
    functionality and flexibility. Honest Estimate Many
    unscrupulous contractors exist.

  41. An anniversary tower is another personalized gift with a handsome presentation; it is a gift tower
    made with boxes filled with their favorite things. Women
    put too much emphasis on the wedding day and not enough time is dedicated to the marriage.
    This picture to the right is a template of a correct
    and formal table setting and is likely much too formal for
    most wedding receptions; unless you are expecting royalty.

  42. Before the release of the Rebel, I was seriously thinking about either a 60D or a
    7D. s sum up the major features we have talked about, and see which digital SLR wins for each one:.
    These filters are often used in order to photography sunsets which
    would otherwise have a dark landscape or white-washed
    sky.

  43. With the demise of the Frua, AC went on building lesser cars and eventually fell into bankruptcy in the late 1970s.
    Try to bear in mind that the way your skin looks will be affected by the season.
    The introduction of the Ferrari 458 Spider has added a nitrous boost the
    the 458 scene causing the mandatory trade up from
    italia to spider enabling the used market
    to gain an influx of 458.

Comments are closed.